Another Massacre, Still No Justice: Nigeria’s Failing Response in Benue

In the quiet hours between June 13 and 14, a wave of terror descended on the rural village of Yelewata in Guma Local Government Area of Benue State, Nigeria. Armed assailants, suspected to be Fulani militia, stormed a Catholic mission compound sheltering internally displaced persons, killing over 100 people in what human rights groups are calling one of the most devastating massacres in recent memory.

The attack, one of several in a series of coordinated assaults across Benue this year, saw entire families trapped and burned alive inside their homes. Witnesses and survivors’ accounts paint a horrific picture of suffering, loss, and abandonment.

“They locked them up and set the buildings ablaze,” said one survivor, whose voice trembled as he recounted watching his neighbours perish in the flames. “The smell of burnt flesh is still in the air.”

The Toll and Dispute Over Numbers

Amnesty International Nigeria confirmed at least 100 civilians were killed in the Yelewata attack. Local officials, including spokespersons for Benue State Governor Hyacinth Alia, placed the death toll lower, at around 45. However, residents insist the real figure is far higher, with many still unaccounted for and others succumbing to injuries without access to medical care.

AP News reported that many victims were “locked inside their homes and burned alive,” corroborating video evidence and eyewitness testimonies. Images circulating online show smouldering ruins, charred remains, and a community paralysed by grief.

“We counted more than 70 bodies in one location,” a volunteer responder told Sahara Reporters. “Others died later in the bush trying to escape.”

A Pattern of Targeted Violence

This massacre is not an isolated event. Just weeks earlier, on June 3, simultaneous attacks across Gwer West and Apa LGAs left over 20 dead and hundreds displaced. In March, armed groups invaded Jato-Aka in Kwande LGA, torching villages and forcing thousands to flee. A local farmer described unusual movements before the assault:

“We noticed strange faces days before. Some of them approached villagers, offering money. We now realize they were planning something,” he said.

According to Amnesty, over 2,600 people have died in Benue State from violence linked to land disputes and herder-farmer conflicts between January 2023 and February 2024 alone.

Community Voices: “We Are Defenseless”

Local sentiment across social media, especially Nigerian forums like Reddit, reflects deep frustration and a loss of faith in the government.

“The police come after the killings and say they’ll ‘investigate,’” wrote one user. “But when citizens defend themselves, they’re treated like criminals.”

Others called for arming local vigilante groups and enforcing state-level anti-open grazing laws.

“Community policing is no longer an option; it’s a necessity,” another commenter stated. “We cannot just sit and wait to be slaughtered.”

A Deafening Silence – and Global Attention

The killings have drawn international attention. On Sunday, Pope Francis condemned the violence during his public address at the Vatican, calling for “security, justice, and peace for our brothers and sisters in Nigeria.”

Rights groups, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and Christian Solidarity Worldwide, have demanded an independent forensic investigation into the Yelewata massacre and urgent humanitarian aid for survivors.

“The Nigerian authorities are failing to protect civilians,” said Isa Sanusi, Director of Amnesty International Nigeria. “This cycle of impunity must end.”

Government Response and Legislative Action

In the wake of the attacks, Governor Hyacinth Alia sent a delegation to assess the affected communities and promised relief materials and increased military presence. The Nigerian Senate has since urged the federal government to enforce the Anti-Open Grazing Law more aggressively and to bolster rural security.

However, many citizens remain skeptical. Past calls for justice have often led to no arrests, and perpetrators continue to operate with impunity.

A Crisis Beyond Benue

The attacks in Benue State are emblematic of a broader crisis in Nigeria’s Middle Belt region, where environmental stress, religious tensions, and the collapse of traditional pastoral routes have turned longstanding disputes into deadly confrontations. Farmers, predominantly Christian, and herders, mostly Muslim, have clashed repeatedly, with civilians often caught in the crossfire.

With thousands displaced and food insecurity deepening, many warn that the situation in Benue is nearing a tipping point.

What Comes Next?

As burial mounds are hastily dug in Yelewata and other villages mourn their dead, the question remains: Will this be the tragedy that finally forces a shift in Nigeria’s response to communal violence?

The people of Benue have seen too many promises. What they demand now is protection, justice, and peace.

“We buried 37 people today,” said a priest at the mission compound. “But what about tomorrow? Who will bury us then?”

MMI